Results · Interpleader · Beneficiary dispute

Husband receives $83,000 life insurance benefit after the rival claim is withdrawn

The insured's mother contested a beneficiary change naming the insured's husband. She withdrew her claim, the court denied the insurer's fee request, and it ordered the fund paid to our client.

  • Interpleader
  • Beneficiary dispute
  • Georgia
Amount
$83,000 (court-ordered payment to our client, plus all accrued interest)
Counsel
Interpleader Law
Result for
The insured's husband, our client
Case
Lincoln National Life Insurance Co. v. Steward
Court
U.S. District Court, Northern District of Georgia
Docket
No. 1:16-cv-03108-MHC
Decided
June 2, 2017
Issue
Competing claims to a life insurance benefit after a beneficiary change made shortly before the insured's death

The insured had an individual life insurance policy with Lincoln National. Shortly before her death, Lincoln received a beneficiary designation form bearing her signature that named her husband as the sole beneficiary, replacing an earlier designation that split the benefit between him and her mother. After her death, both claimed the benefit. The mother contested the change, and Lincoln filed an interpleader in Atlanta in August 2016.

We represented the husband. A few months into the case, the mother withdrew her claim and agreed that he should receive the entire disputed benefit. The court discharged Lincoln, denied its request to be paid its attorney’s fees, and in June 2017 ordered the full $83,810 on deposit, plus all accrued interest, paid to our client.

What it shows. An insurer that interpleads an ordinary beneficiary dispute is not automatically entitled to its attorney’s fees. Here the court found the dispute arose in the normal course of the insurer’s business and left the full benefit for the beneficiary.

Read the court's order

Past results do not guarantee a similar outcome. This summary describes the court's ruling; it is not legal advice about any other case.

Back to all results · Interpleader lawsuits · Beneficiary disputes

Talk to an attorney about your claim

Our attorneys review life insurance disputes at no cost, and there is no fee unless we recover benefits for you. Tell us what happened by phone or through the form.

Call 866-983-6340Free review